When Projects Go Awry: Lessons from Digital Transformation Failures
by Jackson Hull
Summary: Digital transformation projects can fail for many reasons. When one project fails, it can cause a domino effect, impacting operations, stakeholder trust, finances, and company culture. Common reasons for project failure include unclear vision, poor stakeholder engagement, underestimating change management, inadequate risk management, and dependency failures.
To avoid negative consulting partner experiences, companies should ensure cultural alignment, uncover communication styles, prioritize change management, set realistic expectations, and establish strong roles. Open communication and an iterative approach can mitigate catastrophic failures.
Success in digital transformation requires clear vision, engaged stakeholders, proactive risk management, and a trusted consulting partner.
As a Salesforce consultant, I’ve spent the last 4 years of my career helping organizations navigate the complexities of digital transformation. A common thread in my work has been learning from more seasoned professionals why certain projects succeed while others falter. Understanding the root causes of different outcomes has been a cornerstone of being a consultant and business analyst. Today, I want to share key insights on avoiding negative consulting partner experiences and how a single project going awry can escalate into catastrophic failure across an entire digital transformation initiative.
The Domino Effect of Project Failure
Digital transformation is rarely confined to a single system or team. Instead, it involves interconnected processes, technologies, and people working together toward a shared vision (ideally that has been mapped out and agreed upon). When one part of the puzzle fails, the impact can ripple through an organization – if you do not have the right measures in place to resist these issues.
- Disrupted Operations: Failed implementations can disrupt day-to-day workflows, causing inefficiencies and frustration on the client side.
- Lost Stakeholder Trust: When projects fail to deliver, executives and teams often lose faith in the initiative, making future buy-in harder to secure.
- Financial Losses: From budget overruns to sunk costs, failure can strain organizational resources either the client’s by investing in vaporware or by the partner via giving away work and marking time as non-billable.
- Cultural Resistance: Poorly executed projects foster resistance to future changes, creating a culture that fears transformation.
Common Reasons Projects Go Awry
Through my years of shadowing, learning, and consulting, I’ve seen several recurring pitfalls that can lead to project failure. Here’s what to watch for:
- Lack of Clear Vision and Scope Projects often derail due to unclear goals or scope creep. Without a well-defined roadmap, teams struggle to stay aligned, leading to wasted resources and unmet expectations.
- Poor Stakeholder Engagement Successful transformation requires collaboration from all levels of the organization. When key stakeholders are not engaged or aligned, decisions can be delayed, and priorities mismanaged.
- Underestimating Change Management Technology is only one piece of the puzzle. Ignoring the human side of transformation—such as employee training, communication, and resistance—limits adoption and long-term success.
- Inadequate Risk Management Every project faces risks, from technical glitches to regulatory challenges. Failing to proactively identify and mitigate these risks can lead to costly disruptions.
- Dependency Failures Many digital transformation initiatives involve dependencies between systems, teams, and vendors. A failure in one area can cascade into others, causing widespread issues.
I’ve provided a brief overview of these five reasons, but these short paragraphs only scratch the surface—each could easily warrant an in-depth exploration. To delve deeper, I’ll be publishing a dedicated article on each reason and how to mitigate the risk inherent in each, allowing us to examine them in greater detail.
Avoiding Negative Consulting Partner Experiences
Choosing the right consulting partner is critical to avoiding these pitfalls. Here are steps to ensure an alignment:
- Vet Culture Alignment: Ensuring the consulting partner has expertise in the industry is vital but vulture and values alignment is also crucial. Look for a partner who prioritizes understanding your unique values and goals. When the stress comes and the clients start hammering you and your team – you want to know that you have a partner ready to stand their ground with YOU.
- Uncover Communication Styles: Transparency is essential to success in business partnerships. Any partner should provide regular updates, flag potential risks, and collaborate closely with your internal teams if they are going to succeed in the projects you collaborate on. Uncovering communication styles is vital to this. Asking questions like, “How do you respond if a consultant goes dark?” is a great recon device, to sniff out potential poor communication skills.
- Adept Change Management: A worthy consulting partner will emphasize change management, user adoption, and highlight processes that document these things. Ensuring employees are equipped and empowered to use new tools and processes effectively is one indicator of a good partner.
- Set Realistic Expectations: Regularly telling yourself “This is what I can do” and advocating that mindset for your team is a way you can avoid overpromising and underdelivering. Find a partner that will set achievable milestones and a realistic timeline for implementation – this protects your first customers, your team.
- Establish Strong Roles: Clearly define roles, responsibilities, and accountability for your organization and the client. Where there’s mystery there’s margin, and minimizing mystery will ensure decisions are made effectively.
Mitigating Catastrophic Failure
Even with the best planning, and implementing the strategies above, challenges can and will arise. The key to mitigating failure is identifying warning signs early, addressing them decisively, and having team members who are culturally competent, not just technically competent. Here are two ways you can reduce catastrophic failure:
- Foster Open Communication: Good leaders create an environment where team members can raise concerns without fear of retaliation. Unfortunately this happens all the time in corporate environments. People are doing just enough work to not get fired and management is paying people just enough to keep them from leaving. You want the environment you create for your team to be one of curiosity and innovation. This will enable your team to want to try, to innovate, and be creative. A good leader never retaliates when an “inferior” disagrees with a “superior’s” idea. Early problem identification is critical to resolution and communication is critical to problem identification.
- Adopt an Iterative Approach: Using agile methodologies to deliver incremental value is crucial for the success of most projects. An iterative approach allows teams—both client and consultant—to focus on delivering small, manageable chunks of work, fostering adaptability and continuous improvement. By breaking down complex initiatives into smaller, achievable milestones, teams can respond quickly to evolving requirements or unforeseen challenges without derailing the entire project.
Large-scale projects often fail because of their inherent complexity. With too many team members and too many changes being implemented simultaneously, communication breakdowns, misaligned priorities, and scope creep can overwhelm even the most capable teams. Agile practices, such as sprint planning, frequent standups, and retrospectives, help maintain focus and alignment by encouraging regular feedback and collaboration. Ultimately, an iterative approach transforms large, daunting projects into a series of manageable steps, increasing the likelihood of delivering value on time, within scope, and in alignment with the client’s objectives.
Building a Foundation for Success
Digital transformation is a journey, not a destination. Success lies in the details: clear vision, engaged stakeholders, proactive risk management, and a trusted consulting partner. By understanding why projects go awry and taking steps to avoid common pitfalls, organizations can navigate transformation with confidence and achieve lasting value.
For those embarking on their digital transformation journey, remember: the path may be complex, but with the right strategies and partnerships, success is within reach.
Related Articles
Related
No Salesforce interview yet? Here’s some help.
Summary: Job hunting can be tough, and this offers strategies to improve your chances of landing an interview. First, evaluate the business as a customer through their website, social media, and review sites, noting areas for improvement. Next, engage key staff via...
$5 Billion to Bankruptcy – Tails from the Fails
Introduction to Project Failures Hi. I'm Jon Cline, and I'm bringing you a tales from the fails presentation today where we're gonna learn from a prior project that failed for nontechnical reasons as most people don't realize that research over decades shows that...
Keep more clients and seek fewer logos with a Land-for-the-long-term strategy.
Michael Scott has just started a business. He had 2 other employees and very little revenue. With cash reserves dwindling, pressure mounting, and bankruptcy looming, the founder of Michael Scott Paper Company had to do something. Michael knew the industry, had the...